SETTING PRIORITIES|Comparative Risk Report

Project Name: Colorado Environment 2000 Project


    Ranking Results:


    Project Description:


    More:


 
  Ranking Results
 

 
Integrated Ranking Subcommittee's Integrated Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Criteria air pollutants (including the Brown Cloud) general   area specific  
  Loss of wetlands and riparian zones general   area specific  
  Nonpoint source surface water pollution general    
  Pesticides    
Category 2
  Active and inactive mining and milling sites general    
  Aquatic habitats general   area specific  
  Damages from changes in water quantity general   area specific  
  Environmental lead general    
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
  Indoor air pollution/indoor radon general    
  Open space    
  Soil erosion    
Category 3
  Critical wildlife habitat    
  Forest issues general    
  Hazardous and radioactive waste management general   area specific  
  Hazardous and toxic air pollutants general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous and radioactive waste sites general   area specific  
  Recreation opportunities    
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
  Special ecologic and natural resources    
Category 4
  Accidental releases of hazardous materials general   area specific  
  Point source surface water pollution general    
  Threatened and endangered species habitat general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  
  Urban issues    
Category 5
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  
  Noise pollution general    
  Plains issues    
  Visibility degradation in rural and pristine areas general    

[ top ]
 

 
Integrated Ranking Subcommittee's Health Risk Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Criteria air pollutants general   area specific  
  Environmental lead general    
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Indoor radon general   area specific  
  Pesticides    
Category 2
  Mining and milling sites general    
  Nonpoint water pollution general    
  Toxic air pollutants general   area specific  
Category 3
  Accidental releases general   area specific  
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
  Hazardous waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous waste sites general   area specific  
  Point source water pollution general    
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  
Category 4
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  
  Noise pollution general    

[ top ]
 

 
Integrated Ranking Subcommittee's Ecologic and Natural Resource Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Critical wildlife habitat    
  Loss of wetlands general   area specific  
  Nonpoint water pollution general    
  Threatened and endangered species habitat general   area specific  
Category 2
  Aquatic habitats general   area specific  
  Pesticides    
  Soil erosion    
Category 3
  Changes in water quantity general   area specific  
  Forest issues general    
  Mining and milling sites general    
  Open space    
  Special resources    
Category 4
  Accidental releases general   area specific  
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
  Hazardous waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous waste sites general   area specific  
  Point source water pollution general    
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
  Urban issues    
Category 5
  Environmental lead general    
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  
  Plains issues    
  Recreation opportunities    
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Integrated Ranking Subcommittee's Economic and Welfare Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Criteria air pollutants (including the Brown Cloud) general   area specific  
  Damages from changes in water quantity general   area specific  
Category 2
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
  Nonpoint source surface water pollution general    
  Recreation opportunities    
  Soil erosion    
Category 3
  Active and inactive mining and milling sites general    
  Aquatic habitats general   area specific  
  Forest issues general    
  Hazardous and radioactive waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous and radioactive waste sites general   area specific  
  Loss of wetlands and riparian zones general   area specific  
  Open space    
  Pesticides    
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
  Urban issues    
Category 4
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Environmental lead general    
  Hazardous and toxic air pollutants general   area specific  
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Plains issues    
  Point source surface water pollution general    
  Special ecologic and natural resources    
  Visibility degradation in rural and pristine areas general    
Category 5
  Accidental releases of hazardous materials general   area specific  
  Critical wildlife habitat    
  Indoor radon general   area specific  
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  
  Noise pollution general    
  Threatened and endangered species habitat general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Air Technical Work Group's Overall Ranking of Air Issues
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Criteria air pollutants including visibility degradation along the front range (Brown Cloud) and in mountain communities general   area specific  
Category 2
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Indoor radon general   area specific  
Category 3
  Hazardous and toxic air pollutants general   area specific  
  Visibility degradation in rural and pristine areas general    
Category 4
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Noise pollution general    

[ top ]
 

 
Air Technical Work Group's Health Effects Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Indoor radon general   area specific  
Category 2
  Criteria air pollutants general   area specific  
Category 3
  Hazardous and toxic air pollutants general   area specific  
Category 4
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Noise pollution general    

[ top ]
 

 
Air Technical Work Group's Economic Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Criteria air pollutants including visibility degradation in residential areas along the front range and in the mountains general   area specific  
Category 2
  Hazardous and toxic air pollutants general   area specific  
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Indoor radon general   area specific  
  Visibility degradation in rural and pristine areas general    
Category 3
  Acid deposition general   area specific  
  Noise pollution general    

[ top ]
 

 
Land Technical Work Group's Overall Ranking of Land and Multi-Media Issues
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Active and inactive mining and milling sites general    
  Environmental lead general    
  Pesticides    
  Soil erosion    
Category 2
  Accidental releases of hazardous materials general   area specific  
  Hazardous and radioactive waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous and radioactive waste sites general   area specific  
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  
Category 3
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Land Technical Work Group's Health Effects Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Active and inactive mining and milling sites general    
  Environmental lead general    
  Pesticides    
Category 2
  Hazardous and radioactive waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous and radioactive waste sites general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  
Category 3
  Accidental releases of hazardous materials general   area specific  
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  
  Solid waste management general   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Land Technical Work Group's Ecologic Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Active and inactive mining and milling sites general    
  Pesticides    
  Soil erosion    
Category 2
  Accidental releases of hazardous materials general   area specific  
  Hazardous and radioactive waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous and radioactive waste sites general   area specific  
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
Category 3
  Environmental lead general    
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Land Technical Work Group's Economic Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Active and inactive mining and milling sites general    
  Environmental lead general    
  Pesticides    
  Soil erosion    
Category 2
  Hazardous and radioactive waste management general   area specific  
  Inactive hazardous and radioactive waste sites general   area specific  
  Solid waste management general   area specific  
  Underground storage tanks   area specific  
Category 3
  Accidental releases of hazardous materials general   area specific  
  Natural and geologic hazards general   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Water Technical Work Group's Overall Ranking of Water Issues
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Damages from changes in water quantity general   area specific  
  Nonpoint source surface water pollution general    
Category 2
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
Category 3
  Point source surface water pollution general    

[ top ]
 

 
Water Technical Work Group's Health Effects Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
Category 2
  Nonpoint source surface water pollution general    
Category 3
  Point source surface water pollution general    

[ top ]
 

 
Water Technical Work Group's Ecologic Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Damages from changes in water quantity general   area specific  
  Nonpoint source surface water pollution general    
Category 2
  Point source surface water pollution general    
Category 3
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Water Technical Work Group's Economic Damages Ranking
Category 1 Online Information About This Issue
  Damages from changes in water quantity general   area specific  
  Nonpoint source surface water pollution general    
Category 2
  Ground water contamination general   area specific  
  Point source surface water pollution general    

[ top ]
 
  Project Description
 

  Geographical Coverage:
State of Colorado

[ top ]
 

  Project Purpose:
The Colorado Environment 2000 Project was established to identify Colorado's most important environmental issues and to focus attention on ways we can combat problems and take advantage of opportunities.

[ top ]
 

  Ranking Process:
Colorado's Environment 2000 Project involved two phases:

Phase 1 - Risk assessment
Phase 2 - Risk management

The ranking took place during Phase 1. In the first part of this phase, four Technical Work Groups (Air, Land, Water, and Natural Resources) ranked a list of 31 environmental issues based upon the criteria of Human Health Risk, Ecologic Damages, and Economic/Welfare Damages. In the final part of Phase 1, members of the four Technical Work Groups formed the Integrated Ranking Subcommittee and constructed rankings for each of the three criteria and a final integrated list.


[ top ]
 

  Participants in the Ranking Process:
Governmental Agencies
Private Sector/Industry
Public Interest/Nonprofit Organizations
Scientific/Academic Community

All of the above stakeholders groups had representatives on at least one of the Technical Work Groups or Integrated Ranking Subcommittee. The General Public were provided the opportunity to participate at one of two environmental summits coordinated by the Citizen Advisory Committee during Phase 2.


[ top ]
 

  Reference:
Colorado Environment 2000 Governor's Citizen Advisory Committee. Colorado Environment 2000: Final Report of the Governor's Citizen Advisory Committee. Environmental Assessment Program, Office of Environment, Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. June 1990.

Colorado Environment 2000 Technical Work Groups. Colorado Environment 2000: Environmental Status Report. Environmental Assessment Program, Office of Environment, Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. October 1989.

Colorado Environment 2000 Technical Work Groups. Technical Work Groups Ranking Reports & Analysis of Issues Final Draft.Environmental Assessment Program, Office of Environment, Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. August 1989.
http://www.epa.gov/opperspd/futures/nogopher/risk/crexamples/examples/Colorado/index.html


[ top ]
 

  Contact Information:
Gerard Bulanowski
Environmental Assessment Program
Office of Environment
Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment
4300 Cherry Creek Drive South
Denver, CO 80220-3716
phone: (303) 692-3004
fax: (303) 782-4969
http://www.state.co.us/gov_dir/cdphe_dir/cdphehom.html

[ top ]