SETTING PRIORITIES|Comparative Risk Report

Project Name: State of Texas Environmental Priorities Project (STEPP)


    Ranking Results:


    Project Description:


    More:


 
  Ranking Results
 

 
Public Advisory Committee Final Ranking
Very High Online Information About This Issue
  Ground-level ozone (smog) general   area specific  
  Habitat alteration    
  Lead contamination general    
  Loss of biodiversity general   area specific  
  Particulate matter general   area specific  
  Stratospheric ozone depletion general   area specific  
High
  Air toxics general   area specific  
  Ground water quality general   area specific  
  Pesticide contamination    
  Surface water quality general   area specific  
  Waste handling & disposal general   area specific  
Medium
  Abandoned sites & spills general   area specific  
  Flooding    
  Global climate change general   area specific  
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Water availability general   area specific  
Low
  Atmospheric deposition general   area specific  
  Food safety general    
  Lawn chemicals    
  Public drinking water quality general   area specific  
  Radiation general    
  Soil erosion   area specific  
Very Low
  Electromagnetic fields general    
  Noise pollution general    
  Odor pollution    
  Pests    
  Toxics in the home general   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Public Advisory Committee Preliminary Ranking
1.   Lead contamination general    
2.   Loss of biodiversity general   area specific  
3.   Habitat alteration    
4.   Stratospheric ozone depletion general   area specific  
5.   Ground-level ozone (smog) general   area specific  
6.   Particulate matter general   area specific  
7.   Air toxics general   area specific  
8.   Pesticide contamination    
9.   Surface water quality general   area specific  
10.   Waste handling & disposal general   area specific  
11.   Ground water quality general   area specific  
12.   Abandoned sites & spills general   area specific  
12.   Indoor air pollution general    
13.   Global climate change general   area specific  
14.   Water availability general   area specific  
15.   Flooding    
16.   Atmospheric deposition general   area specific  
17.   Public drinking water quality general   area specific  
18.   Lawn chemicals    
19.   Radiation general    
20.   Food safety general    
21.   Soil erosion   area specific  
22.   Pests    
23.   Toxics in the home general   area specific  
24.   Noise pollution general    
25.   Electromagnetic fields general    
26.   Odor pollution    

[ top ]
 

 
Human Health Final Workgroup Ranking
1.   Indoor air pollution general    
2.   Particulate matter general   area specific  
3.   Ground-level ozone general   area specific  
4.   Lead contamination general    
5.   Food safety general    
5.   Ground water quality general   area specific  
6.   Air toxicant general   area specific  
7.   Surface water quality general   area specific  
7.   Waste issues general   area specific  
7.   Water availability general   area specific  
8.   Global climate change general   area specific  
8.   Stratospheric ozone depletion general   area specific  
9.   Public drinking water quality general   area specific  
10.   Pesticide contamination    
11.   Lawn chemicals    
11.   Radiation general    
11.   Toxics in home general   area specific  
12.   Flooding    
13.   Pests    
14.   Electromagnetic fields general    

[ top ]
 

 
Ecological Final Workgroup Ranking
1.   Habitat alteration    
2.   Loss of biodiversity general   area specific  
3.   Global climate warming general   area specific  
4.   Surface water quality general   area specific  
5.   Air toxics general   area specific  
5.   Atmospheric Deposition    
5.   Particulate matter general   area specific  
6.   Waste issues general   area specific  
7.   Soil erosion   area specific  
8.   Pesticide contamination    
9.   Water availability general   area specific  

[ top ]
 

 
Socioeconomic Final Workgroup Ranking
1.   Habitat alteration    
2.   Pesticide contamination    
3.   Abandoned sites and spills general   area specific  
4.   Waste handling & disposal general   area specific  
5.   Water availability general   area specific  
6.   Ground-level ozone general   area specific  
7.   Particulate matter general   area specific  
8.   Surface water quality general   area specific  
9.   Flooding    
10.   Radiation general    
11.   Lead contamination general    
12.   Stratospheric ozone depletion general   area specific  
13.   Air toxicant general   area specific  
14.   Ground water quality general   area specific  
15.   Global climate change general   area specific  
16.   Public drinking water quality general   area specific  
17.   Noise pollution general    
18.   Odor pollution    
19.   Atmospheric deposition general   area specific  
Analyzed But Not Ranked
  Electromagnetic fields general    
  food safety    
  Indoor air pollution general    
  Pests    

[ top ]
 
  Project Description
 

  Geographical Coverage:
State of Texas

[ top ]
 

  Project Purpose:
To develop risk-based priorities for protecting and enhancing the environment of Texas.

Several project objectives were also identified:

- to quantitatively and qualitatively characterize the relative risks (using existing data and studies) of identified problems to human health, ecological systems, and the impacts they may have on socioeconomic welfare, or the quality of life in Texas;
- to rank and prioritize environmental problems based on their estimated risks and public values;
- to encourage the development of partnerships among citizens, industry, government agencies and environmental groups to solve environmental problems;
- to provide for increased public participation in the environmental decision-making processes; and
- to produce information and documentation for general public education regarding the nature of environmental risks.


[ top ]
 

  Ranking Process:
The State of Texas Environmental Priorities Project was implemented in two phases:

Phase 1 - Risk assessment and ranking
Phase 2 - Risk management

The ranking took place during Phase 1. During this phase, three Technical Workgroups (Ecological, Human Health, and Socioeconomic) constructed separate rankings of the environmental issues identified by the Public Advisory Committee (PAC). The PAC integrated these three rankings based upon the Technical Workgroup reports and additional information contributed by PAC members. After constructing a preliminary ordinal ranking, based upon paired-voting, the PAC decided that consensus was best reached by categorical ranking, leading to the PAC Final Ranking.


[ top ]
 

  Participants in the Ranking Process:
Governmental Agencies
Private Sector/Industry
Public Interest/Nonprofit Organizations
Scientific/Academic Community

All of the above stakeholder groups had representatives on at least one of the Technical Workgroups or the Public Advisory Committee. While the General Public were not directly involved in the ranking process, their input was sought for the subsequent risk management phase (Phase 2).


[ top ]
 

  Reference:
State of Texas Environmental Priorities Project. State of Texas Environmental Priorities Project Volume 1: Final Overview Report. Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission. June 1997.

[ top ]
 

  Contact Information:
Sylvia Amaya
Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission
P.O. Box 13087
Austin, TX 78711-3087
phone: (512) 239-4811
(512) 239-4303
http://www.tnrcc.texas.gov/

[ top ]